Topic started by nafri (@ 203.143.25.140) on Mon Jul 8 05:09:22 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

It seems to be Kamal is punishing or taking a sort revenge from Tamil Audience for the failures of his great movies (Hey Ram, Mahanadhi, Guna......... even Aaalavandan).

He might be fedup with the audience appreciation for those movies, where he gets good response for moives like Thenali, Pammal..., Michel.... and Pancha.........

It is not healthier to Tamil Film Industry, since he is the best actor the tamil cinema ever produce, who took the tamil film industry (including sivaji) to the internationl stage.

Responses:

• Old responses
  
• From: Kumar (@ myangup0.connect.com.au) on: Fri Sep 6 00:55:52
  
  OK, I'll try that again......
  Saradha, "Sathya" was in reference to your question on showing sisterly love.
  
  
• From: Milton (@ 203.116.61.131) on: Fri Sep 6 01:07:37
  
  seelan,
  Why you have addressed to me ..I don't understand.
  
  
• From: kasi (@ 219.92.195.157) on: Fri Sep 6 13:09:24
  
  kamal: almost every movie got bed scene and kissing scene
  rajini: not at all
  
  kamal: his movie cannot be seen with brothers/sisters and parents exp hey ram,alavanthan
  
  rajini:" U" for all his film
  
  i think this is enough too show that rajini movies are much more better than kamal's movie
  
  
• From: Milton (@ palo8.pacific.net.sg) on: Fri Sep 6 14:45:43
  
  In this case Ramarajan movies are even better.
  
  
• From: Saradha (@ 207.239.176.82) on: Fri Sep 6 15:27:01
  
  Kumar,
  
  Clarify this, I would appreciate if you are really honest here,
  
  Are you saying that, response to Sisterly love by KH in Sathya is better than Rajini's acting in Mullum-Malarum (Rajini-Shoba).
  
  Again, Are you saying response towards motherly love, nanaaga nanillai thaye song in TTT is better and KH acting in TTT is better than Rajini's acting in Ammavai vanngatha uyirillayae song in Mannan?
  
  
  
• From: Saradha (@ 207.239.176.82) on: Fri Sep 6 17:44:38
  
  Kumar:
  
  
  """Seriously, if Rajini movies are based on English ones, it does not bother me."""
  
  So?
  
  """When I watch his films, I just know that all I'm getting is base and thoughtless entertainment""
  
  That is YOU! and your perspecctive but this is a big world. Nobody said that you should also hate or dislike KH.
  
  ""Even when "Arunachalam" was made, I
  couldn't care less when I found out that it was based on "Brewster's Million".""
  
  I thought, it was admitted, discussed already specifically addresssing to you. How many times you want to go through this? Please go through the earlier postings.
  
  
  ""In fact, I thought that it was great to see something different from the same, old
  familiar Tamil movie storyline."""
  
  Really? Again, it is you!
  
  I thought, people those who have been appreciated as highly "creative" and doing movies of high quality should not be cheap and definitely not plaigirizers! Of course that is me!
  
  """It just intrigues me that you are very personally affected with Kamal's movies (and for some strange reason, with his personal life)."""
  
  Now, we got a psychiartist here!
  
  I do not care what intrigues who. I have posted what I feel about Kamlhasan and his creativity.
  
  Nobody asked you to agree with me.
  
  You should have listened to Milton, I believe.
  
  
• From: Kumar (@ myoon0.connect.com.au) on: Sun Sep 8 18:41:13
  
  Saradha,
  
  "Are you saying that, response to Sisterly love by KH in Sathya is better than Rajini's acting in Mullum-Malarum (Rajini-Shoba).
  
  Again, Are you saying response towards motherly love, nanaaga nanillai thaye song in TTT is better and KH acting in TTT is better than Rajini's acting in Ammavai vanngatha uyirillayae song in Mannan?"
  Well, going by your response above, then isn't this also your opinion- that Rajini was better in the scenes with his mother & sister. To me, Kamal was better. To you Rajini is better. Anyway, the examples I gave you (Sathya, Naanaghe naanillai) was in response to your questions:"Show me (educate me)one movie in which Kamal shows his motherly love properly..." & "I have not seen a single movie he shows his siterley love". I have shown you these examples. Whether you think Rajini was better is really your opinion, and I respect it.
  "I do not care what intrigues who. I have posted what I feel about Kamlhasan and his creativity.
  
  Nobody asked you to agree with me. "
  Yup, nobody asked, that is why I am not agreeing with you.
  Please also don't think I hate Rajini, just because I am a Kamal fan. I liked his older movies. Mullum Mallarum was fantastic. 16 Vayithinile was great. 6 to 60 was excellent acting and so was Netrikkan. Thalapathy was so good that I saw it several times. Somewhere down the line, he has adopted this formula which he uses in his newer movies. The reason may be due to his fans who want Rajini in this stereotypical role. The movie formulas are also the same: intro song, villians against him, he falls, he rises, he triumphs, he preaches, etc. That is why I now see his present movies as entertainment, nothing more , nothing less.I am longing for Rajini to really use his talents. He can act very well; but I feel that his full potential is not realised in his newer movies.
  
  
• From: Kumar (@ mytee0.connect.com.au) on: Sun Sep 8 18:43:40
  
  Saradha,
  p.s, I did read Milton's response, but I am having a better time discussing this with you! Isn't the Forum all about this?
  
  
• From: Saradha (@ dialup-209.246.133.98.dial1.dallas1.level3.net) on: Sun Sep 8 19:17:40
  
  OK, Thanks and good luck to you both Milton and Kumar!
  
  
• From: c (@ ac9eb0c1.ipt.aol.com) on: Sun Sep 8 21:12:37
  
  From: kasi (@ 219.92.195.157)
  
  >kamal: almost every movie got bed scene and >kissing scene
  >rajini: not at all
  
  >kamal: his movie cannot be seen with >brothers/sisters and parents exp hey >ram,alavanthan
  
  >rajini:" U" for all his film
  
  >i think this is enough too show that rajini >movies are much more better than kamal's movie
  
  In Veera, Rajini puts a fish/something into Meena's blouse. I guess this is very normal compared to kissing.
  Do you recommend that we watch it with brothers/sisters and parents? Great message for kids?
  
  Note: I am not saying that other actors' movies don't have such scenes. I am not saying that kissing or bedroom scenes are watchable with the entire family.
  
  
  
  
• From: Nehru (@ j168.srb33.jaring.my) on: Sun Sep 8 22:13:37
  
  If Male actors can let themselves be fondled, caressed and kissed by woman(like what Prasanth did in Mega Star Nite in Malaysia), then can our men also do the same to the Indian female actors?
  
  
• From: Jawarar (@ j168.srb33.jaring.my) on: Sun Sep 8 22:19:57
  
  Kamal will do anything for a Oscar. He is a looser. He puts the same thing in all his movies. There are few things that you can see him doing on all his movies. When he dances, no matter in what song, he likes to jump and touch his both feets. This is one of the. After Rajini's Tillu Mullu;s success, Kamal got obsssed with car chase scenes. Ever since, there is always a car chase scene in his movies.
  
  
• From: Kumar (@ myoon0.connect.com.au) on: Mon Sep 9 01:15:33
  
  Was there a car chase in Dhevar Magan?
  
  
• From: Milton (@ solar-gw.zapsurf.com.sg) on: Mon Sep 9 01:49:22
  
  kumar,
  Please read this.
  http://www.thinnai.com/pl0909021.html
  
  
• From: K (@ proxy.iis.com.br) on: Mon Sep 9 04:26:41
  
  Undoubtably, kamal is one ofe the best actor, india had ever seen. Rajanikanth is just a doll, he dont know the a.b.c.d of acting. He is a dirty old fellow who should retire to save tamil people. He looks like very ugly, one of the ugliest face in cinema. I think even senthil and kountamani are better actors than this old ugly fellow.
  
  
  Saradha is the bloody bitch and the big fool and also the idiot. I suspect she/he has the sex relation with this rajanikanth.
  
  
• From: Milton (@ palo8.pacific.net.sg) on: Mon Sep 9 07:56:44
  
  Mr K,
  Please maintain some decency.Saying Rajini doesn't know ABCD of acting is too much.He is next to kamal in acting.
  
  If you can argue with points rather than using dirty and uncultured words,you are welcome.Otherwise atleast don't do personel attack just for the reason you are sitting in a remote place.
  
  
• From: Rasigan (@ 206.26.206.66) on: Tue Sep 17 12:01:23
  
  Mr.K
  
  We all like Kamal acting, but it doesnt mean that you have to pull down Rajinikanth. Rajini is gr8 in his own ways. He has his own style and actions. His BABA might be a failure (bcoz of story and all) but there are many movies which Rajini has given super duper hits. So pls. be kind enough.
  
  
• From: Partha (@ ) on: Fri Oct 4 11:52:01
  
  
  Guys,
  
  Its no point in arguing about Kamal, as we all know and even the whole India knows that he has got the capability of doing any sort of role.
  
  After Mr. Shivaji Ganesan, Kamal is the only person who can go near and touch the chair of that great actor who is no more now...
  
  If u have seen all his movies, just try to watch Kamal's reaction to his opponent's delivery leaving out the action...That can tell u a story.
  No matter we all know that he is one of the best comedian being an hero himself...
  
  
  I think no more arguements is needed in this matter...Let us agree that Kamal is a master piece in Tamil film industry and let us give hands in welcoming his new inventions...
  
  Thanks...
  
  Tamilan....
  
  

Want to post a response?