Topic started by ram (@ 61.11.76.118) on Wed Oct 17 09:06:27 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

Shivaji, Kamal and M.R. Radha are the greatest legends in Indian Flm History.
Shivaji is the born Genius
Kamal is a (learn) Genius Growing day by day.
M.R.Radha the scene stealer in any scene.
Post your comments.

Responses:

• Old responses
  
• From: Ali (@ cpe0080c6eb09f2-cm014390026941.cpe.net.cable.rogers.com) on: Thu Jan 29 13:57:18
  
  Kamal Hasan Is A Great Actor Indeed, Mithun does have a lot of talent he won a national award in his first movie, yes kamal is a over all better actor probbaly the top 3 of all time.....other actors to consider naseerudin shah, amazing actor also won a national award, he also does movies in hollywood, nana patekar elite acting in hindi cinemas also has a national award, amazing job in Khamooshi could have won an oscar if it was in Hollywood. Atul kulkarni, very underated actor did elite acting in Hey ram And Chandi Bar won national awards for both movies and the list goes on, some actors are underated and not even considered........
  
  Both Tamil & Hindi Cinema Produce Elite Acting, neither is superior than another.
  
  
• From: ajith (@ suw183068.wright.edu) on: Mon Feb 2 10:32:45 EST 2004
  
  Ajith also an actor who is one of the greatest! He will prove himself very soon!
  
  http://groups.yahoo.com/group/actorajith-fans
  
  
• From: Rajesh (@ inet-netcache2-o.oracle.com) on: Mon Feb 9 20:32:01 EST 2004
  
  Kamal is the best Actor in the World, he deserves something more than an Oscar, Hats off to Kamal your the Best
  
  
• From: mohan (@ 202.88.235.221) on: Sat Feb 14 15:19:50 EST 2004
  
  hi tamilians u seems too selfish when analysing actors.first of all for u people actors from out side tamilnadu does not come into consideration.that is a big mistake.for eg: take mohanlal ,mammotty,, thilakan from kerala .take amitabh from hindi, rn't they good?for me mohanlal is the best actor india has ever seen.pls don't think that i tells so coz i am a keralite.to be frank i have not seen any one who acts so naturally.imagine in ur ming an elder brother talking to a younger one.then see each of these actors performances in similar scenes.i bet
  mohanlal's will be the most similar to the original.as far as shivaji is concerned, i doubt he gets due respect outside india as an actor,coz the truth is that heis an over expressing actor.he is not even to be considered for the best actor tag coz he is so unnatural an actor.
  
  
• From: sakthivel (@ 220.226.23.248) on: Tue Feb 24 08:11:34 EST 2004
  
  
  its a good topic
  
  these three guys are TOP stars in tamil field
  
  unfortunately sivagi & M.R.Radha passed away
  but now the only on men who proved "the meaning of acting and all"
  
  that's KamalHaasan..
  "The Man Of Versatility"
  " Brain Behind the Beauty"
  i love him ..
  
  ragards
  shakthi
  
  
  
• From: sakthivel (@ 220.226.23.248) on: Tue Feb 24 08:19:14 EST 2004
  
  
  its a good topic
  
  these three guys are TOP stars in tamil field
  
  unfortunately sivagi & M.R.Radha passed away
  but now the only on men who proved "the meaning of acting and all"
  
  that's KamalHaasan..
  "The Man Of Versatility"
  " Brain Behind the Beauty"
  i love him ..
  
  ragards
  shakthi
  
  
  
• From: sakthivel (@ 220.226.23.248) on: Tue Feb 24 08:19:48 EST 2004
  
  
  its a good topic
  
  these three guys are TOP stars in tamil field
  
  unfortunately sivagi & M.R.Radha passed away
  but now the only on men who proved "the meaning of acting and all"
  
  that's KamalHaasan..
  "The Man Of Versatility"
  " Brain Behind the Beauty"
  i love him ..
  
  ragards
  shakthi
  
  
  
• From: sakthivel (@ 220.226.23.248) on: Tue Feb 24 08:31:35 EST 2004
  
  
  its a good topic
  
  these three guys are TOP stars in tamil field
  
  unfortunately sivagi & M.R.Radha passed away
  but now the only on men who proved "the meaning of acting and all"
  
  that's KamalHaasan..
  "The Man Of Versatility"
  " Brain Behind the Beauty"
  i love him ..
  
  ragards
  shakthi
  
  
  
• From: sakthivel (@ 220.226.23.248) on: Tue Feb 24 08:32:48 EST 2004
  
  
  its a good topic
  
  these three guys are TOP stars in tamil field
  
  unfortunately sivagi & M.R.Radha passed away
  but now the only on men who proved "the meaning of acting and all"
  
  that's KamalHaasan..
  "The Man Of Versatility"
  " Brain Behind the Beauty"
  i love him ..
  
  ragards
  shakthi
  
  
  
• From: Ramanan (@ wbar14.tampa1-4-4-149-080.tampa1.dsl-verizon.net) on: Thu Apr 29 00:54:58
  
  
  It is certainly fair to include actors from other regions when putting together a list that calls for a comprehensive summary, So here is my Top 5 all time :- ( I am including only those Artists in
  the LEAD roles, otherwise the list may
  be too LONG )
  
  1) Sivaji Ganesan :- He has not only portrayed
  such a variety of characters, but his depth of
  emotions and attention to detail in his roles are
  awesome. His strength is not just in Dialogues, Or
  Crying Out Loud, Even when he is a Mute Listener his Gestures are tell-tale vital. Anybody who underrates him, has just no idea of his skills.
  
  2) Sanjeev Kumar :- Absolute Favorite in Hindi.
  Whether it is comedy or romance or action, his dedication to the role is second to none. Incidentally, he has confided to more than a few that he looks up-to 'Sivaji' as the Role-Model.
  
  3) Kamal Hassen :- He has GOT A LOT OF VARIETY.
  He has adapted well in physique as well as Gestures to Plethora of roles that are far beyond
  any stereo-type. Only gripe I have of him is
  he is too 'INFLUENCED' by WESTERN/Foreign techniques and maybe he has lost some individuality along the way.
  
  4) Mohan Lal :- Have'nt seen too many of him, But have to give him credit for the wide recognition
  he has got for his absolute transformation in a few of his roles. But his Physique cannot transform beyond a Limit. As an actor, to mesmerize the Audiences in variety of roles ... you must pretty much ERASE their minds of YOUR OWN personality .. but his Fat Pouching Figure is too
  much to hide.
  
  5) Ashok Kumar / Dilip Kumar / Kishore Kumar
  
  They are legends themselves. The roles portrayed are limited in vareity nevertheless complete and
  Essay a total control over the histrionics. For those who know KK as only a singer, rest assured that he is a SOLID actor too and has won accolades from many.
  
  
• From: kamli (@ 149.226.255.200) on: Thu Apr 29 09:13:26 EDT 2004
  
  raj kapoor and kamal hasan-- cannot beat them.
  keralites are selfish.
  they support only mohanlal.
  
  
• From: Thamizhan (@ 61.1.200.75) on: Thu Apr 29 09:58:52 EDT 2004
  
  Sivaji,Kamal easily qualify to the list..but where do we get the logic of adding M.R.Radha here...man ..he was too monotonous to bear.
  Its a gross insult to a legend like Shivaji,to add M.R.Radha's name there.
  
  
• From: anand (@ 210.18.90.1.sify.net) on: Thu May 20 10:13:45
  
  Sivaji Ganesan is easily the greatest ever indian actor.Nobody comes even close to him.
  
  Kamal is vastly overrated. There are many actors better han him - sanjeev kumar, Om puri, naseeruddin shah etc
  
  
• From: quake (@ 202.68.154.144) on: Thu May 20 17:29:23 EDT 2004
  
  http://www.iomx.com
  
  
• From: ukw (@ 128.252.181.24) on: Thu May 20 17:38:03 EDT 2004
  
  
  I always remember him as CHARCTERS
  
  *ambigAbathy
  
  *manOharA
  
  *kirukku aNNA
  
  *sikkal shanmugasundaram,
  
  *prestige Padmanabhan
  
  *barristor Rajnikanth
  
  *S P Coudhary
  
  * Chinna Durai
  
  * mUkkaiyA sErvai
  
  * a family man cum LONER in muthal mariyAthai
  
  * vIra Pandiya kattabomman
  
  What are characters in some people's dictionary,
  
  Must be some weird-looking clown I guess.
  
  
• From: Karthikeyan (@ ppp-219-65-139-73.bng.vsnl.net.in) on: Tue Jun 1 05:50:22
  
  You are all wasting time in talking abour Kamal.
  
  Talk about Shivaji, MR Radha, Rajini, and others not Kamal. He is only a copy writer.
  
  
• From: ajay bhatia (@ dialpool-210-214-89-231.maa.sify.net) on: Tue Oct 19 00:09:33
  
  It is quite ridiculous to pick an actor from your own region and call him the greatest actor in the world.It merely reflects the senders ignorance and lack of exposure to cinema.Kamalhassan is a good actor ,and a regular on the filmfest circuit,therefore he would probably take his fans claims of him being the worlds greatest actor with a pinch of salt.Before venturing into best actor lists I suggest that fans break a few mental barriers and watch a few dozen films of the masters-Bergman,Kurosawa,Fellini,Antonioni,Godard,Truffaut,Tarkovsky,Ray,Adoor ,the list is endless!
  
  

Want to post a response?