chandiyar
Topic started by sss (@ cache90.156ce.scvmaxonline.com.sg) on Thu Mar 20 06:52:40 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
Responses:
- Old responses
- From: SARAVANAN (@ 61.247.249.182)
on: Thu Jan 8 09:20:47 EST 2004
I too agree..Kamal is one of the biggest and best artist in Indian Cinema ... but he burns the other producers fingers for his experiments...and he tries comedy and masala movies for his own production....what a selfishness...and people talk as if he is a great one....i love even all the failed movies and experiments like Aalavandhan, Guna etc.,its a success or not...its surely a class movie...my only question is...why u do classics only at other man's cost ...and why not in Rajkamal films...otherwise Kamal is a greatest artiste..and as a tamilian...I just salute his talents...which no other big director has got.... (SOME ONE HERE HAS COMPARED HIM WITH MANIRATNAM...ABSOLUTE B S**T....MANIRATNAM IS CHEATING MOVIE GOERS ... HE IS JUST A GOOD MARKETING GUY...THATS ALL....EXCEPT MOUNA RAGAM AND ANJALI...ALL HIS MOVIES ARE PURE S**T AND NOTHING ELSE...DONT COMPARE KAMAL WITH MANIRATNAM...THAT DEGRAGES KAMAL....PLS DONT DO IT)p
- From: BABA (@ 203.76.163.3)
on: Sat Jan 10 00:28:35 EST 2004
Kamal's Experimental Movies on others Production which are only AALAVANDAAN and ANBE SIVAM
All other experiments are his own productions. Guna, Hey Ram, Rajaparvai, Viradam, Vikram ........ are films which did not do well.....
Aboorva Sagodarargal, Kurudhi Punal, Maglir Mattum (Nasser), Kadamai Ganniayam..... (Sathyaraj), Devar Magan..... are his own movies which made him to earn something.
Guys take a list of Kamal's Hit movies and you could find out almost all the 90% of those are on others production.
Even now he has done VIRUMANDI in his own banner, and his doing two more under RAJKAMAL.........
So I dont agree on saying that " but he burns the other producers fingers for his experiments...and he tries comedy and masala movies for his own production...."
- From: BABA (@ 203.76.163.3)
on: Sat Jan 10 03:27:27 EST 2004
Kamal's Experimental Movies on others Production which are only AALAVANDAAN and ANBE SIVAM
All other experiments are his own productions. Guna, Hey Ram, Rajaparvai, Viradam, Vikram, Mahanadhi ........ are films which did not do well.....
Aboorva Sagodarargal, Kurudhi Punal, Maglir Mattum (Nasser), Kadamai Ganniayam..... (Sathyaraj), Devar Magan..... are his own movies which made him to earn something.
Guys take a list of Kamal's Hit movies and you could find out almost all the 90% of those are on others production.
Even now he has done VIRUMANDI in his own banner, and his doing two more under RAJKAMAL.........
So I dont agree on saying that " but he burns the other producers fingers for his experiments...and he tries comedy and masala movies for his own production...."
- From: sashbasha (@ 219.95.19.242)
on: Tue Jan 20 04:05:12 EST 2004
seeing all u people arguing dazzles me. I agree with most of u people that kamal is a great actor, but maybe not a good director. saravanan, open your eyes and look into manirathnam’s movies. manirahnam is a brilliant director. as kamal is in acting, manirathnam is in directing. did u watch kannathil muthamittal, it’s a superb movie. this is one movie story that almost completely revolves around the character “Amutha”. have you seen any successful tamil movie that is like this. think saravanan.
- From: vimal (@ ppp-219.65.111.115.chn.vsnl.net.in)
on: Fri Jan 23 15:13:31
Mr.K.Balachander has right told that the biggest mistake done by kamal is being born in Tamilnadu. Yes he is absolutely right. Not only him we must also include the names of Nadigar thilagam Sivaji Ganeshan and Maestro ilayaraja in this category. Their creativity that we could not explain by words. We must feel it. I don't know why these people comparing maniratnam and kamal. Ofcourse maniratnam is good director thats all. Kamal is the best allrounder. We people always doing the same mistake. Not only today, just few years back they had talked about AR. Rahman and ilayaraja. These type of conversation comes from people who has not at all having sense. Is it possible to compare tree and plant? As told by baba Kamal's 90% Hit movies came from others production. Thats true. Being a tamilzhan we must do only one thing to kamal...that is not to give wrong comments about his films..and then try to avoid bloody masala movies. Oscar award is just like an local prize given to students in their school(US). We are all college students don't expect it. The great legends(both sivaji and kamal) won't look for it.
- From: Roshan (@ 220.247.204.38)
on: Sat Jan 24 00:10:30 EST 2004
That's a great post Vimal!! But our thamizhans will never realise the value of such talented people.
- From: moses (@ 219.95.176.177)
on: Tue Jan 27 23:51:21 EST 2004
poganda ponda
- From: Baba (@ 203.76.163.3)
on: Wed Jan 28 04:06:47 EST 2004
Pongal Results
http://www.cinesouth.com/masala/hotnews/new/28012004-2.shtml
Tell your friend about this topic
Want to post a response?
Back to the Forum