Why the Comedy actor Vivek is always criticising Indian Tradition and our Hinduism in his films?

Topic started by Ram (@ 202.156.2.253) on Tue Sep 11 21:53:54 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

From: winter (@ gwextclu.seagate.com) on: Sun Aug 26 22:41:21


Mr.Ram...

silar nerathil avar sollugirathu unmmai yai
taan yirukke...smile

winter



From: Sridhar (@ star.zapsurf.com.sg) on: Mon Aug 27 04:55:38


It shows he lacks the talent to make genuine comedy.Comedy panna mathavanga sirikira mathiriyum sindhikira mathiriyum pannanum.Aana manasu punn badi comedy panna ve koodathu



From: rajan (@ 202.9.180.163) on: Mon Aug 27 00:16:18


Imitation to some extent can be enjoyed. Where is originality, creativity , a style for himself ? Think of original comedies by Nagesh, senthil-gowndamani . vivek is un comparable with them.






From: Hello (@ lunar.zapsurf.com.sg) on: Tue Aug 28 03:29:22


Vivek is performing well. His main theme is to destroy " Muda Nambikai"



From: man (@ lan-202-144-73-33.maa.sify.net) on: Tue Aug 28 06:02:47


if so then why only hindusism? mooda nambikkai?

why not other religions?



From: Hello (@ lunar.zapsurf.com.sg) on: Tue Aug 28 06:16:23


This shows that Hindus got more "Muda Nambikai"



From: winter (@ gwextclu.seagate.com) on: Wed Aug 29 03:59:19


Yes Mr/Ms Hello...

I agree wz u...

winter



From: alagane ratchasi (@ 202.188.210.28) on: Wed Aug 29 05:56:44


'This shows that Hindus got more "Muda Nambikai"'

If u critise other religion's 'muda nambikai', they will never leave u alone, whatmore alive. It shows that Hindus are very tolerant. FULLSTOP.



From: MAGESH GOVINDARAJAN (@ 203.197.83.89) on: Wed Aug 29 06:02:59


In the current era of comedians like vadivelu,goundamani,senthil,vaiyapuri,charlie etc. VIVEK is unbeatable for the following reasons.
timing
sense of humour on any topic
nakkals
sarcastic remarks about moda nambikais
indianising western culture
imitating others voice
jokes on current affairs
critsing chitti and chittappa ( kodieswaran)

he is comparable to all current heros of kollywood.





From: anu (@ ppp-200-1-99.bng.vsnl.net.in) on: Wed Aug 29 11:42:52


if u really want to know, why not ask vivek himself..

comedy is to be enjoyed..looking for other things in it will spoil the whole thing.



From: Hello (@ solar.zapsurf.com.sg) on: Wed Aug 29 21:51:17


Most of them enjoying Vivek's comedy. Even Hindus laugh and claps when he is criticising the Hindu god's. That means they agree what he has siad!



From: kalgi (@ ce2.time.net.my) on: Wed Aug 29 22:51:37


Ah....come on guyz vivek is a better comedian than the previous ones,cu`s he is an educated person.Not making stupid `A` jokes like kaundamani,senthil,vadivelu.His jokes are watchable.He is critisizing Sanathana Darma,i don`t think so,his good alternative to get rid of muda nambikkaigal in Hinduism.Be practicel guyz....hail!!!to chinna kalaivaanar vivek!!!keep up the good work.

Many mooda nambikkaigal nam sanathana mathathin unmai uruvai seerkulaiyacheigirathu.



From: francis (@ 210.186.220.184) on: Wed Aug 29 23:37:19



i personally like the way he act. it is simply sponteneous and i beliew he is the follower of n.s. kalaivanar.

keep up the good work vivek.



From: winter (@ gwextclu.seagate.com) on: Sun Sep 2 21:41:32


Mr.Hello u are absolutely right and i agreed
wz u...




From: stg (@ 12.151.162.48) on: Mon Sep 3 01:50:38


Dont ask why he is criticizing traditions and customs. First, does he has a right or not to criticize. Second whether there is merit in his criticism.

Everyone has got a right to criticize and since customs & traditions are not the property of anyone no one can object to the criticisim even if it is in bad taste. When every comedian from surli rajan can get away with double etendere and obscene dialogues I think vivek is an angel when compared to those chaps. Of course I prefer nagesh and thangavelu for their comedy which is devoid of rancour and vulgarity



From: Alter ego (@ bhmas07-71-182-204.cw-visp.com) on: Mon Sep 3 10:59:39


Vivek has said a few times that he is not against Hinduism, and that he is only against malpractices followed in the name of religion, which I think isn't wrong.



From: winter (@ gwextclu.seagate.com) on: Mon Sep 3 22:37:45


Whatever he ( vivek ) said there's a facts !!
and one more things is that MOST of the dialogues
is frm the writter not him. He just follow for that is his career ( job ). Everyone has their own
style to tackle people !!!



From: Roshan (@ 203.94.89.145) on: Tue Sep 4 01:32:15


From what I have heard, the dialogues of his part are his own stuff and almost all Directors leave it to him to handle it.

Yes he is doing a good job. He not only critices Mooda Nambikkai but also critices certain foolsih, meaningless and ridiculous things like TV mega serials, present day politics, politicians and even Tamil cinema.

There's no need to raise questions against his commedy, because it helps the audience enjoy and more than anything it helps them THINK.



From: winter (@ gwextclu.seagate.com) on: Wed Sep 5 23:24:24


yes Roshan..




From: kr (@ lunar.zapsurf.com.sg) on: Thu Sep 6 04:05:28


In the movie " Poovellum Onn Vaasam", vivek will tell Kovai Sarala to do funny things when she became "Amman". Kovai Saralla will become normal.
That means Vivek is trying to say that "Amman" doesn't has the power. Is it so?



From: Wise Man (@ ppp-185-1.bng.vsnl.net.in) on: Sat Sep 8 11:02:57


Everyone has a right to criticise anything. The intention behind criticism is what is of consequence. Some genuinely try to analyse and expose faults that are embedded in a system, others find it fashionable to criticise and degrade anything that is traditionally Indian or traditionally Hindu as superstition or as out of sync with current times.

Sometimes it takes a lifetime of experience to understand even the basics of these customs and beliefs and how they have developed over the life of a culture. In the enthusiasiasm to criticise what is not yet understood by the individual, let it not happen that the wisdom will dawn at a later day when the person has already made an @ss of oneslf.



From: Vaasthu Sastra (@ dialpool-210-214-4-78.maa.sify.net) on: Sun Sep 9 12:03:33


Guyzz,
A nice tidbit, u must all hv seen Vivek criticising "Vaastu Sastra" in almost all his films. The story in some magazine went that he has got his house altered as per Vaastu redone by co-actor Dhamu, who is some sort of expert in these stuff
"Practise what u preach !!! "


Responses:


  Tell your friend about this topic

Want to post a response?

Post a response:

Name:

E-mail:


Please Reload to see your response


Back to the Forum