Topic started by arvind (@ 61.11.74.28) on Fri May 24 01:34:27 .
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

we have been discussing here about the top10 tamil films we have seen so far.
but can we single out a movie from the top 10 and grant it the best movie ever. well, the nominees of the best films are

1)Andha naal
2)Deiva Magan
3)16 vayadhinilae
4)moondram pirai
5)Uthiri pookal
6)Nayagan
7)Devar Magan
8)Mahanathi
9)Sethu
10)Hey Ram.

i might have left a few movies. now can u tell me the best movie of the above 10 or if u have a top10 post them and tell which is the best movie. the different factors for the ratings are,
1)casting-10 points (the cast could even be new faces , but right people at the right place)

2)realism - 20 points

3)overall acting of the crew- 15 points

4)strong social theme- 25 points

5) trend setter -50 points

6) awards ,recognition- 10 points

7) box office sucess- 15 points

8) technical aspects(cinematography,editing etc..) -35 points.

9)music(mainly background score)- 15 points

10)story line - 40 points

11) originality - 30 points.

12) screenplay- 60 points

13) novel dialogues - 20 points.

overall------------- 335 points

i think my best ever movie will be Nayagan with a whooping 290 points only losing points for orinality. the second best is HEY Ram with 270 points losing points in trendsetter category and in overall acting category.

please give ur list

Responses:

• From: Kajan (@ wc05.ym.rnc.net.cable.rogers.com) on: Fri May 24 02:30:02
  
  I fell Alagi and Barathi should come on the top of the list I could rarely c films with much reality ? Even Kannathil Mutthamittal also not with 100 % reality!
  
  By the way I don't have time to analysis in deep scale
  
  
• From: baba (@ 203.106.211.71) on: Fri May 24 04:04:45
  
  arvind pls send some time on other useful activity ur mum is shouting at u from the kitchen can u hear that come on lah man go to kicthen help ur mum potong sayur... movie analysis wont bring anything profit to u.... unless u r trying to see actress boop without any bra ha ha ah
  
  
• From: viko (@ cache6.156ce.scvmaxonline.com.sg) on: Fri May 24 09:10:05
  
  i think the best tamil ever
  is heyram
  without using yer point system
  
  
• From: raju (@ webport-cl6-cache1.ilford.mdip.bt.net) on: Sat May 25 21:17:51
  
  16 vayadiniley OR thappu thaalangal
  
  
• From: Shakhuni (@ 203.197.148.122) on: Thu May 30 05:36:34
  
  I might sound partial, but i am honest.
  
  this is my ratings and with some changes.
  
  1) Thulluvadho Ilamai (perfect 100)
  2) Snehidhiye
  3) Aalavandhan
  4) Hey Ram
  5) Paandavar Bhoomi
  6) Moondram Pirai
  7) Aarilirundhu Arubadhu vrai
  8) Edhir Neechal
  9) Aalaya Mani
  10) Baama Vijayam
  
  
• From: Raghu (@ 212.2.14.241) on: Thu May 30 07:26:39
  
  Hey
  
  what about
  
  1) Thalapathy
  2) Anjali
  
  
• From: viko (@ 203.106.81.159) on: Thu May 30 12:02:39
  
  ragu and shahkuni are thevi diya mavengal
  
  
• From: MAAKAN (@ 210.187.116.154) on: Thu May 30 12:44:21
  
  the best means only one that is HEY RAM
  
  
• From: Shakthi (@ bangdp-35-138.mantraonline.com) on: Fri May 31 20:39:33
  
  Anda naal
  Pudiya paravai
  Aval appaditaan
  Hey ram
  Guna
  Housefull
  Moondram pirai
  sigappu rojakkal
  6il irundu 60varai
  
  
• From: Ramesh (@ 61.11.82.178) on: Sat Jun 1 06:36:40
  
  Hey Ram
  
  
• From: frd (@ 202.86.171.20) on: Mon Jun 3 14:30:57
  
  kannathil muthamittal
  
  
• From: vengayam (@ 203.200.84.66) on: Tue Jun 11 02:50:42
  
  uthiri pookal
  azhiyaatha kolangal
  moga mull
  are strong contenders for best movie.
  Hey ram is a pathetic joke to figure in the list.
  kathalikka neramillai can figure in the list for being a trend setting comedy.
  But Uthiri pookal will win hands down.
  
  
• From: Filmfan (@ 164.164.96.174) on: Tue Jun 11 05:18:41
  
  Hey Ram
  Guna
  Mahanadhi
  Michael Madana Kamarajan
  Kadhalika Neramillai
  Devar Magan
  
  
• From: Jitin (@ 61.11.76.39) on: Tue Jun 11 05:20:52
  
  Uthiri Pookkal
  Pasi
  Aval Appadi Thaan
  Pathinaaru Vayathinile
  Iruvar
  
  
• From: Milton (@ sbproxy2.mystarhub.com.sg) on: Tue Jun 11 05:25:37
  
  "Hey ram is a pathetic joke to figure in the list."-Vengayam
  
  What else we can expect from a Vengayam
  
  
• From: Milton (@ lunar-gw.zapsurf.com.sg) on: Tue Jun 11 13:21:15
  
  Raththa Kanneer-by Great M.R.Radha
  
  
• From: viko (@ cache6.156ce.scvmaxonline.com.sg) on: Thu Jun 13 07:34:29
  
  vengayam,
  hey ram is world class
  
  
• From: Raghu (@ 212.2.14.241) on: Thu Jun 13 09:05:24
  
  How about Thalapathy?
  
  
• From: Arjun (@ 202.144.77.168) on: Fri Jun 14 08:40:19
  
  "Hey Ram" doesn't even deserve a remote mention in a list of best Tamil movies. It was highly self-indulgent, pretentious and absolutely superficial. Kamal Haasan's platform to tell the world about his self-presumed intelligence. The same modus operandi backfired in "Aalavanthaan" as well. He should better stick to straight-from-the-heart scripts and see how he can bring out delightful results like "Thevar Makan" and "Mahanadi".
  
  
• From: viko (@ cache6.156ce.scvmaxonline.com.sg) on: Sat Jun 15 05:41:09
  
  most director or screenplay writer will have his
  views bombarded in his flim.
  as for heyram(dealing with sensetive issue) views must come from soures which are fair which origantes from intelligence(what kamal has researched on)
  if views comes straghit from the heart 4 hey-ram like movies problems will arise like riots
  
  
  
• From: MADDYFAN (@ 233.d.005.mel.iprimus.net.au) on: Sun Jun 16 08:06:44
  
  MINALE AND RELAX R DA BEST FILMS EVA CREATED IN DA TAMIL FILM HISTORY, FULL STOP!
  
  
• From: usha (@ 212.219.91.237) on: Mon Jun 24 07:12:40
  
  i can't accept with the best film of heyram . in my view sethu is the best one.
  
  

Want to post a response?