Topic started by jhanvimenon (@ 210.19.249.45) on Sun Aug 29 22:49:22 EDT 2004.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

the vaanavil paadal thiran pohti 2004 just breeze away with a such unexpected result. we've spend more than 7 weeks of our time to watch the show n we were shocked to see the result
on my opinion, it was such a waste to watch the show.
they should banned the programme.no point thr they invite judges frm india but final decisions are made by msian judges !!!!!!!!!

Responses:

• From: Vaanthi] (@ j15.ttk36.jaring.my) on: Mon Aug 30 02:44:34 EDT 2004
  
  Yes, I agree with the comments. The result was unexpected. We are not happy with the winners. All the good singers didn't get the award. What's happening? We feel waste to watch it.
  
  
• From: a (@ 219.95.17.181) on: Mon Aug 30 07:18:17 EDT 2004
  
  wat a stupid result, Nakeeran should get 1st and Sidarthan should be 2nd!!!
  
  
• From: Sarala (@ j43.ttk34.jaring.my) on: Wed Sep 1 05:42:00 EDT 2004
  
  We are not happy with the RESULT!!! Vanavil must do something BETTER or Choose a correct JUDGE for the FINAL POOTHI.
  
  
• From: kumar (@ 203.92.128.3) on: Wed Sep 1 09:51:10 EDT 2004
  
  wat we have to do is...all the guys must boycott the potti..so many years not even a guy have won the car...wat a waste..even if they r talented..they r just a waste for the show
  
  
• From: jhanvimenon (@ 210.19.249.45) on: Wed Sep 1 20:51:13 EDT 2004
  
  hi kumar
  its true wht u have said
  it seems tht for 4 yrs girls are going back with the 1st prize
  this yr competition, guys are much better thn girls
  but the "kia optima" given to jayashree
  oh my goodness!!!!!! she killed us by singing the same song again n again
  i feel so irritated !!!!!!!
  
  
• From: Sarala (@ j98.ttk34.jaring.my) on: Thu Sep 2 04:30:00 EDT 2004
  
  That's right, guys.
  
  
• From: mahi (@ 218.111.180.54) on: Wed Sep 8 05:40:55 EDT 2004
  
  hi jhanvimenon,
  what ur telling is 100% right,
  i think nakeeran & sidhartan should get the 1st & 2nd accordingly,
  that jayashree with her song 'ninnei sharanadaithen' really iiritating.
  very disappointing results!!!!
  
  
• From: sachulatha (@ 219.92.212.78) on: Wed Sep 8 08:03:12 EDT 2004
  
  i am sorry to say this but i think you people are in the first place not fit to watch this programme ..do u really know what is paadal thiraan potti all about ?..i am an indian classical singer from india , and it was indeed a surprise to see the 3 of them sing so well ( the 3 of them that i am talking abt are the top three winners )...
  nakiran or sidhartan ..well..i think people were voting nakiran for his looks..now i am not saying that he cant sing ,yes he can..but not upto what is expected from a good singer ...well , if you people are well trained classical singers , then you people will definately know what i am talking abt , the same goes with sidhartan ..
  
  what i personally beleive ..what i , as a classical singer feel is , the three of them ..who won the first ,second and third placing respectively , deserves the victory.
  
  
• From: SDAD (@ palo3.pacific.net.sg) on: Thu Sep 9 01:27:32 EDT 2004
  
  LET ME TELL U SOMETHING
  
  THE NAME =PADAL THIRAN POTTO = TAMIL NAME
  
  WATCHED BY ALL TAMIL
  
  MOST OF THE CONTESTANTS = TELUGU
  
  NAKIRAN , SIDDHARTHAN; JAYASRI,ALL SRIS, ALL DEWIS = ALL TELUGU
  
  I WATCHED SEMIFINAL AND MANAGED TO BET WITH MY FRIENDS THAT ONLY TELUGU'S WILL BE SELECTED AND IT HAPPENS
  TELUGU MANAGEMENT DOING THE THING SO THAT ONLY TELUGUS WILL WIN THE COMPETITION
  
  WHETHER U STUPID TAMILS SEE IT OR NOT
  
  THE TELUGUS WILL FOR SURE ORGANIZE IS AGAIN AND GIVE THE PRIZE AGAIN TO TELUGU
  
  MEANWHILE TAMILS GO AND KILL EACH OTHER AND MAKE OURSELF TO LOOK STUPID AND THE LOWEST CASTE
  
  FED UP READY BEING A TAMIL
  
  
  
• From: jhanvimenon (@ 210.186.3.247) on: Fri Sep 10 09:13:00 EDT 2004
  
  hi
  suprising guyss
  pls do not raise up "caste ' issue here
  it is just a forum to share our opinions
  we dont vote according to good looks as u are blaming abt
  it is just a view
  are u really to any of the 3 top winners
  i'm a singer 2 n in my opinion 3 of them was really worst
  at least i feel tht the guy ganesan should get any of the 3 winners place
  are u trying to tell tht only classical singers n who learn classical music can judge them
  music is pleasant thing tht melts our heart
  first of all, all the classical music leaners should be banned frm the taking part as it is not fair to th others
  
  
• From: Henry Gurney (@ ) on: Tue Sep 21 02:36:56
  
  ya this year judgement is a disaster.. I don't really truest in Dina and the and the last director's judgement....
  
  Yes, Jaysree have rendered the songs very well (ninai saran adaithen) but unfortunately she couldn't do well when they have to sing 3 songs with same ragaam. The way she sing like in classical way.. (she have sing s janaki's voice to her own tune)she don't know how to change her voice from classical to the normal songs.
  
  and the 2 fellow also.. out.. the no. 2 is... like nose bloking. and the 3 one... ok a bit..
  
  nakireen did well in the previous but on final he look too cool and and the songs became liveless.
  
  Mary did well on the final 3 songs and the song poo malarthadu, I don't know why she didn't get.....
  
  sidarthan did well too.. he suppose to get number 2 and mariadass to be no. 3. I'm not really fond of his voice, but my family member all said that he have sung the song very well...
  
  I hope vanavil will bring a good judge next time.. if they choose a judge, let them until end. different people different taste.
  
  
• From: tt (@ 218.111.109.9) on: Tue Sep 21 03:49:48 EDT 2004
  
  The same thing happen last year....I thought it will change this year but the same thing happen...
  Last year Deva had given 4th place to the girl(Anu I think) but all the sudden, when they announce the winner, it was the Anu who become the winner. So not only judges, there is another person involve too....
  
  
• From: Sara (@ pngfwpr01.png.intel.com) on: Tue Sep 21 04:11:32 EDT 2004
  
  Well, seeing last year's results one shud expect the un-expected from Astro. Jayshree did sing well enough to be the winner. But too bad, some good singers were eliminated in the beginning itself. The only complain I have on this year's show has to be the host's make up and attire. Outmost atrocious !! Did they make her up in the dark? The colours, the hair, etc. Mega disaster. Complete eye-sore even. One example is at the website above.
  
  
• From: Shana (@ 219.93.174.107) on: Sun Sep 26 23:51:54 EDT 2004
  
  I think sachulatha comments was 100% right, Jaysree really did well, and guys don't think this year's paddal thiran potti was a disaster because girl won the contest again cause from my opinion she really did well. I know most of you like nakiran and sidhartan but unfortunately they didn't do well in the final stage that is the fact, for a singer classical tune is very important and in my opinion Jaysree has the best classical voice of all the contestants.
  
  Hello friend how do you know, Jaysree is telegu don’t simply say lah. It is true don’t raise up "caste ' issue.
  
  Every contestant from the first week to the final stage was good, but there should only be three winners and the judges have done a good job. They know who did well and who didn’t.
  
  Bye.
  
  
• From: kausalyia (@ 219.93.174.107) on: Fri Oct 1 07:12:24 EDT 2004
  
  Hmm...even though i m a gurl myself but i have to say dat astro is being a very unfair....how is it there r 6 guys and 2 girls in the finals competing against each other....and not even one guy was gud enough to beat ms. jayashree.....dat seems a little dumb in my point of view...not to say dat she didn't do well....she did great but i fell dat da guys did better....futhermore...how is it every year a girl wins...this competition is getting a little predictable...as if it is obvious dat a gurl is gonna win da car very year....
  
  
• From: TAMIL (@ palo3.pacific.net.sg) on: Mon Oct 4 02:11:00 EDT 2004
  
  SIMPLE
  
  NO NEED TO MAKE DEEP ANALYSIS
  
  SHE IS TELEGU AS THE PERSONS WHO MANAGED THE EVENT
  
  INFACT ALMOST ALL THE CONTESTANTS ARE TELUGU
  
  TAMIL PEOPLES ARE FOOL IN EVERY WHERE
  
  IN TAMIL, MALAYSIA, SINGAPORE AND EELAM
  
  
• From: Aru (@ beacon-ext.nus.edu.sg) on: Fri Oct 8 10:45:22 EDT 2004
  
  Hi sachulatha,
  
  I would like to let you know that we malaysians do have some knowledge when it comes to music and we don't have to agree with indians like you in all issues.
  First of all we don't blindly support someone just because of his looks and I personlly believe singing does not only involve music but also good language and pronounciation. So don't try to insult us just by saying we're supporting someone for his looks. Please don't try to tell me that you're an indian thus you have better knowledge in the language department as well... We do see how Tamil 'lives' in your country.
  
  
• From: Solli Adipen j6 (@ j110.iph40.jaring.my) on: Thu Oct 14 15:10:23 EDT 2004
  
  jayashree did well in singing unnai saranain...
  but, in the final, all the other songs she sang is not good
  but siddarthan stole the show by singing some of the tough song with power,
  nakiran is good only in one of the final song, thats all, overall, sidarthan shld be the WINNER and nakiran for 2nd
  also, i notice jayashree did some tricks by REPEATEDLY sing the SAME SONG even in the final when others sing variety of songs, thats unfair,
  thats cheating,
  anyway, she already used the car and still using it,
  but i pity sidarthan and nakiran but let them be remembered that many ppl like me voice out they r the winner
  congrats guys
  
  

Want to post a response?